avion, airline, plane, aeroplane.jpg
Photograph: Pixabay.com / Unsplash

A deal between the European Union and Canada to share airline passenger information is in breach of fundamental EU rights and should not be implemented as agreed, an advisor to the European Union's top court recommended Thursday.

The assessment was welcomed by data protection advocates, who warned that the final decision by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) could have consequences for a similar EU-wide deal finalized earlier this year. But others criticized the advice as "irresponsible."

The sharing of so-called passenger name record (PNR) data - including the names, addresses and credit card numbers of plane travellers - is considered important to tackle terrorism, but has proven controversial in Europe due to privacy concerns.

The agreement with Canada was signed by EU governments in 2014, but has to be approved by the European Parliament before taking effect.

Before doing so, EU lawmakers decided to ask the ECJ whether the deal, which involves the collection of European citizens' personal data, is in line with the bloc's treaties.

Some elements of the PNR deal run counter to the EU charter of fundamental rights, Advocate General Paolo Mengozzi found.

He is one of 10 advocates general who provide legal opinions to the EU court, which will likely need several more months before issuing its definitive opinion.

Mengozzi flagged provisions that allow Canada to process, store and disclose PNR data beyond what is strictly necessary to prevent and detect terrorist offences and serious crime, and to transfer data to third countries that could pass it on further.

He based his opinion in part on a landmark ECJ ruling last year that struck down an EU-US data sharing deal known as Safe Harbor, after it was challenged by Austrian activist Max Schrems.

It is the first time the Luxembourg-based judges have been called upon to rule on the compatibility of an international agreement with EU fundamental rights, the court said.

Mengozzi's advice was welcomed by European Digital Rights, a data protection campaign group. If followed by the court, it could have a significant impact on other PNR agreements, including an EU-wide deal signed off by the parliament in April, the group said.

But conservative EU lawmaker Timothy Kirkhope called the opinion "irresponsible," arguing that it "not only threatens our fight against terrorism but also the fight against child exploitation, trafficking and drug smuggling."

EU-based airlines already share PNR data with security forces in Canada, Australia and the United States. The parliament had demanded new agreements with all three partners to better bring them into line with EU standards.

Latest news

Syrian government vows retribution for Homs attacks that killed 42

The Syrian government vowed retribution for synchronized attacks on Saturday in Homs City that left 42 security personnel dead and reportedly involved up to six suicide bombers.

Between 250,000 and 300,000 Croatians suffer from rare diseases

Rare Disease Day, observed on February 28, was marked in Zagreb's Cvjetni Trg Square on Saturday.

German police shoot man who rammed car into pedestrians in Heidelberg

Police in Germany shot a man who rammed a car into pedestrians in the south-western town of Heidelberg on Saturday.

Egypt's al-Sissi orders cabinet to help Christians fleeing Sinai

Egypt's president Abdel Fattah al-Sissi ordered the government on Saturday to take all necessary measures to help Christians who escaped northern Sinai after the Islamic State militia killed at least six of them over the past month.

SDP MP calls on citizens to raise their voice against restriction of women's rights

Josko Klisovic, a Social Democrat member of the Croatian parliament, on Saturday called on all Croatians to raise their voice against a policy turnaround on women's rights after Croatia took a conservative position in a discussion on human rights in the Council of the European Union.

Egypt court acquits Mubarak's aide of 22 years

An Egyptian court on Saturday acquitted one of ousted president Hosny Mubarak's closest aides, ruling he was not guilty of corruption and illicit profits.

EU ambassador to Albania Romana Vlahutin under 24-hour police protection

EU Ambassador to Albania Romana Vlahutin and her family have been given 24-hour armed police protection due to threats she has been receiving lately, the Austrian paper Der Standard said on Saturday, explaining that the threats were linked to Vlahutin's monitoring of a reform of Albania's judiciary designed to curb corruption in that country.

Italy deports two over suspected contact with Berlin attacker

Italy has deported two Tunisian asylum seekers who have been classed as a danger to national security, the Interior Ministry in Rome said on Saturday.

Croatian PM says HEP IPO most efficient model for INA buyout

Prime Minister and HDZ leader Andrej Plenkovic on Saturday commented on models for buying back Hungarian oil and gas company MOL's stake in INA, saying that an initial public offering of 25% of the HEP power company's shares to obtain funds for INA's buyout was "the most efficient, fastest, simplest and cleanest option with the fewest participants, which enables the state, which is the owner (of HEP), to control the process in its entirety."

Iraqi forces advance in western Mosul amid fierce resistance from IS

Iraqi forces were making advances in western Mosul, entering a new neighbourhood north of the airport, amid fierce resistance from Islamic State militia, a security official said Saturday.

Mugabe says he will not step down as he celebrates 93rd birthday

President Robert Mugabe, the world's oldest head of state, marked his 93rd birthday with lavish celebrations in Zimbabwe on Saturday, despite a deepening economic crisis in the southern African country.

Poll: Majority of Greeks want new savings reforms to avoid elections

Over 60 per cent of Greeks are in favour of striking a new deal to unlock a fresh bailout from creditors as an alternative to snap polls, according to a survey commissioned by the To Vima newspaper.