britain flag, engleska zastava.jpg
Photograph: Photo by UpSticksNGo Crew, used under CC BY

If British voters opt to leave the European Union, their government would have to redefine its trade ties with the bloc.

The Brexit camp, which has campaigned for an end of EU membership, and the camp that wants Britain to stay in have debated whether Norway, Switzerland or Canada could be models for how to keep close ties with the EU without being a member.

Economists and political scientists have pointed out that in all these scenarios, Britain would still have to follow a significant number of EU rules in return for favourable trade conditions.

THE NORWAY MODEL: The Scandinavian country has close ties with the EU as both sides are part of the European Economic Area (EEA), also known as the European single market.

In order to profit from this relationship, Norway has to accept the principle of free movement of workers and services with the EU.

In addition, the oil-rich country has to support the EU's 15 poorest members with 388 million euros (439 million dollars) per year.

"Becoming part of the EEA would not generate substantial fiscal savings for the UK government," Swati Dhingra and Thomas Sampson of the London School of Economics concluded in an analysis.

Despite these concession, Norway does not have any say in EU decisions and legislation.

An expert report commissioned by the Norwegian government in 2012 found that "although Norway takes a keen interest in the EU, that interest is not fully reciprocated."

THE SWITZERLAND MODEL: The small but wealthy country has taken a different approach by concluding 120 agreements with the EU on access to various markets, services and education.

Like Norway, Switzerland is obliged to implement various EU norms and to pay financial contributions to reduce economic disparities within the 28-country union.

Switzerland does not have full access to the EU financial services market, even though banking is a major sector of the Swiss economy.

Therefore, Swiss banks have set up operations in EU financial centres like London.

In case of a vote for Brexit, British financial institutions might also have to shift operations to Ireland or to financial hubs on the continent.

The case of Switzerland shows how difficult it is to maintain such an intricate web of treaties, according to Sabine Jenni, a political scientists at the ETH Zurich university.

"The Swiss relationship with the EU is a patchwork established in long rounds of diplomatic negotiations and requiring constant reparation," she wrote in a commentary.

The Swiss government has been trying to negotiate immigration limits for EU citizens, but the talks are stuck as the EU has refused to start talks on the matter.

THE CANADA MODEL: The EU has recently negotiated a free-trade deal with Canada that is more comprehensive than any other such agreement that the bloc has concluded.

Once the deal comes into force, it will remove nearly all tariffs on industrial, agricultural and fishery trade.

Also on the upside, Canada is not obliged to contribute to the EU budget.

"But arguably the biggest challenge the EU-Canada deal poses as a potential model for UK-EU relations after Brexit is that it only grants limited services liberalisation," said Vincenzo Scarpetta, a policy analyst at the Open Europe think tank in London.

Canada's relationship with the EU is therefore "by no means comparable to being a member of the single market," he wrote in an analysis.

Related stories

Latest news

Mosque attended by Berlin attacker Amri closed, police confirm

The mosque in Berlin attended by Berlin truck attacker Anis Amri has been closed. The mosque is permanently closed, read a note in German and Turkish on the door of the prayer rooms which was seen on Tuesday.

German army to expand to almost 200,000 soldiers

Germany's Bundeswehr, plans to expand its number of professional soldier to 198,000 by 2024 because of increasing duties, the German Defence Ministry announced on Tuesday.

Fired Audi engineer says he was 'sacrificed' for emissions scandal

A fired Audi engineer was "sacrificed" amid the ongoing VW group diesel emissions scandal, his lawyer claimed in court on Tuesday as he contested his client's dismissal.

French police arrest three over suspected terror plans, source says

French authorities have arrested three men in relation to suspected plans to carry out attacks in the country or travel to Syria, a source close to the investigation told dpa on Tuesday.

UN: Trial against Gaddafi regime was unfair, flawed

Former members of the Gaddafi regime did not get a fair trial in Libya because the proceedings were so seriously compromised, the United Nations criticized in a report on Monday.

Croatia remains Bosnia's biggest trade partner in 2016

Croatia is still the most important foreign trade partner to Bosnia and Herzegovina, according to figures released by the BiH Chamber of Foreign Trade which show that in 2016 the two countries' trade had gone up.

Red Cross: Bodies of 74 migrants wash ashore in Libya

The bodies of 74 migrants washed ashore in Libya, in the north-western city of Zawiya, a spokesman of the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) said Tuesday.

Ancelotti makes charity donation after middle finger gesture

Bayern Munich coach Carlo Ancelotti has agreed to donate 5,000 euros (5,200 dollars) to a charity run by the German football federation DFB following his middle finger gesture towards Hertha Berlin fans.

Azerbaijan's long-time leader Aliyev appoints wife as vice president

The long-time president of the oil-rich, Caspian Sea nation of Azerbaijan, Ilham Aliyev, appointed his wife, Mehriban Aliyeva, as vice president on Tuesday.

HSBC reports 62-per-cent fall in annual profit, blames one-off costs

Banking giant HSBC on Tuesday reported a 62-per-cent fall in its annual profit last year, blaming losses incurred from the sale of HSBC Bank Brazil and other one-off costs.

Le Pen quits meeting with Lebanon's Sunni cleric over headscarf row

France's far-right presidential candidate Marine Le Pen walked away from a meeting on Tuesday with Lebanon's senior Muslim Sunni cleric after she refused to wear a headscarf.

Podravka revenues up 15 pct, profit up 54 pct

The Podravka Group that operates in two main business segments: food and pharmaceuticals, generated a net profit in 2016 of HRK 182.4 million, which is 54.7% more than in 2015 without taking into account the one-off effect of consolidating the Zito company or deferred tax returns of Belupo in 2015, according to the company'y unaudited financial statements released on Tuesday.

Chinese prefecture requires all cars to install tracking devices

A prefecture in China’s troubled north-western province of Xinjiang is requiring all vehicles to install satellite tracking devices, a move that comes just weeks after authorities warned against cars being used for terrorist attacks.

Rohingya activist urges companies to stop investing in Myanmar

Foreign companies need to stop investing in Myanmar in order to stop the country's discrimination against its Muslim minority Rohingya, a prominent Myanmar activist said Tuesday.

ASEAN concerned about militarization in disputed South China Sea

South-East Asian countries are concerned about growing militarization in the disputed South China Sea and stressed the need for dialogue to ease tensions, the Philippines’ foreign minister said Tuesday.